Subhas Nair, a Singaporean of Indian origin, has made a profession of ruffling feathers in Singapore, attracting 1000’s of followers together with his daring raps on controversial and delicate subjects together with racial points.
However his work, alongside sister Preeti, has additionally attracted the eye of the authorities within the intently managed metropolis.
“I’m right here to face up for my neighborhood and as a rapper, my position is to talk fact to energy – not only for my individuals, however for all of us who’re dwelling below capitalism and this authoritarian regime,” 29-year-old Subhas advised Al Jazeera. “Mainstream media can say what they need – they’re mouthpieces of the state anyway; a state whose mom tongue is cash.”
Subhas’s rhymes are designed to amplify the voice of what he calls the disenfranchised “Brown folks” by means of subversive, witty humour.
Almost 75 p.c of Singapore’s inhabitants is ethnic Chinese language, however the island can also be dwelling to ethnic Malay Muslims, Indians and different minorities.
Subhas’s debut album Not a Public Meeting (2018) addressed a spread of native sociopolitical points, from conflicting notions of masculinity to rising up as a low-income minority – all issues that Subhas has skilled personally. The rapper can also be concerned in mutual help work centred round justice for migrant staff – a lot of them from Bangladesh and India – who’re among the many most disenfranchised communities in Singapore.
A pointy wit and tongue appear to run within the household: Preeti – higher often called the YouTube counter-influencer Preetipls – not solely raps, however can also be a proud “plus-size” lady; the very reverse of the thin, pale-skinned fashions who are likely to dominate Singapore media.
Preetipls’s debut single THICC, launched in 2018, was an ode to plus-size femininity and a whistle blow in opposition to the macho-dominated, Western-influenced requirements of hip-hop music.
For our second version of IWD video characteristic we now have @plspreeti ❤️ Clever phrases from her concerning the significance of intersectionality!
— Common Music Singapore🎮 (@universalmusg) March 17, 2022
“Rising up, there was hardly any plus-size illustration within the hip-hop music I used to be uncovered to, until it was closely hyper-sexualised,” Preetipls advised Al Jazeera. She has 41,500 Instagram followers and a YouTube channel with greater than 16,000 subscribers.
“THICC was all about how I felt about my physique on a superb day and the way it was time for THICC ladies like me to thrive within the highlight.”
The duo’s rising profile as tongue-in-cheek social commentators, nonetheless, has additionally ended up muzzling their caustic rhymes.
A battle in opposition to ethnic windmills
The Nairs’ first brush with the legislation was in July 2019, after they uploaded a self-produced rap video in response to an commercial for an digital fee service from the Singapore authorities that featured Chinese language Singaporean actor Dennis Chew made up in brownface to impersonate an Indian character.
The Nairs’ expletive-laden video – a remix of Australian feminine rapper Iggy Azalea’s tune F**ok It Up – focused Singaporean Chinese language, accusing them of being privileged, racist and exploitative of Indians and different minorities.
The video was shortly taken down, however Subhas was given a two-year conditional warning for allegedly trying to advertise in poor health emotions between Chinese language Singaporeans and the island’s minorities. Subhas was warned that he could be prosecuted if once more discovered responsible of any comparable offence.
Chew, who additionally dressed up as a Malay lady in a hijab for the business, apologised for participating, whereas the e-payments firm additionally mentioned it was sorry.
Singapore’s Information-Communications Media Improvement Authority (IMDA), which regulates the business, mentioned that whereas the commercial was in poor style and “precipitated offence” to minorities, it didn’t breach the native Web Code of Observe.
Nonetheless, the Nairs’ video does appear to have had some optimistic impact.
“Because the incident, I haven’t seen ‘brownface’ occur in Singapore,” Preetipls mentioned. “Earlier than the ‘brownface’ video, mainstream media has been wholly insufficient in masking race points, and it’s nonetheless various/unbiased media that commonly offers protection on racist incidents.”
Regardless of the warning, in July 2020 Subhas posted a response to a video of ethnic Chinese language Christians making hateful remarks in opposition to one other neighborhood.
In October of that 12 months, he additionally commented on a murderous brawl that left 31-year-old Satheesh Gobidass, an Indian Singaporean man, useless at Orchard Towers, one in all metropolis state’s earliest retail complexes and now higher identified for its shady nightlife.
The final straw for the authorities was when Subhas used a cartoon drawing of the put up on the Orchard Towers incident to embellish the stage on the launch of his album Tabula Rasa on March 11 final 12 months on the now-closed various tradition area The Substation.
On 1 November 2021, Subhas was charged with 4 counts of trying to advertise in poor health will between Singapore’s completely different ethnic teams over issues of faith and race with the police saying the rapper had breached the situations of the sooner warning.
Accompanied by Preetipls, Subhas confirmed little contrition.
He walked to court docket sporting a T-shirt emblazoned with the face of Nagaenthran Dharmalingam, a 34-year-old Malaysian Indian man who was then on dying row after being convicted of a drug trafficking offence.
Nagaenthran’s attorneys argued he was intellectually disabled to a level that he couldn’t have made an knowledgeable choice. A final-ditch attraction to cease his execution was rejected and Nagaenthran was hanged final month.
“It was simply me profiting from the platform and conserving the concentrate on the collective work forward of us in abolishing the dying penalty and saving the lives of Naga and everybody on dying row,” Subhas advised Al Jazeera.
“In Singapore, so many teams have been displaced, disenfranchised and systemically focused. As I’ve mentioned on a monitor earlier than, it appears like ‘the gallows are the one place we get illustration.’”
Rapping in a tough place
The clampdown on the Nairs is simply the latest instance of how Singapore polices not solely probably the most rebellious types of widespread music and tradition – as lately as 2019, Swedish black steel combo Watain had its debut Singapore present cancelled resulting from complaints by native Christian teams – but additionally satire and social commentary.
In 2021, a sequence of incidents renewed debate on the character of ethnic relations within the city-state, the place racial riots in 1964 left some 22 individuals useless and tons of injured.
In a single incident, a Chinese language man kicked an Indian lady within the chest uttering racial slurs as he did so, whereas in one other, an older Chinese language man confronted an interracial couple who have been out collectively in a park, questioning their relationship. Weeks later, a Malay lady was sentenced to jail for insulting an Indian lady on a public bus.
man within the singapore tshirt actually mentioned “i feel it’s racist that indians marry a chinese language” WTFF
credit score: FB/Dave Park Ash pic.twitter.com/gqvtzU7uqh
— YEOLO™ (@tzehern_) June 6, 2021
After the incidents went viral on social media, Minister of Finance Lawrence Wong admitted Singapore had “seen considerably extra [racist incidents] instances than regular” within the earlier months, including that it was “more than likely due to the stress of COVID-19”.
Wong pressured Singapore remained a multiracial society that doesn’t “devalue” variety, however “we settle for and have a good time it”.
In the meantime, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong devoted a 3rd of his 2021 Nationwide Day speech to race and faith, and mentioned the bulk needed to be extra delicate to the issues of the minorities. He additionally introduced a brand new Upkeep of Racial Concord Act to encourage individuals to reside collectively higher.
“Legal guidelines could not, by themselves, make individuals get together with each other higher,” Lee mentioned. “However legal guidelines can sign what our society considers proper or fallacious, and nudge individuals over time to behave higher.”
After contemplating a responsible plea, Subhas has determined to go to trial over the costs in opposition to him.
A court docket date is pending.
“I don’t have illusions of grandeur or aspirations to be wealthy or well-known,” Subhas mentioned. “I simply need to communicate fact to energy and run as laborious as I can whereas the baton continues to be in my hand.”